- or it am not American Idol results night.
There were 4 strong performances last night (save for Archeleta forgetting some words) and two mediocre ones. Based on performances I expected either Brooke White or Jason Castro to get the axe.
I was mentally preparing myself to say goodbye to Brooke. Instead both she and Jason were safe.
Sayesha Mercado and Carly Smithson were at the bottom… and I’ve been down on Sayesha for some time now, so for me to say she was very good Tuesday speaks volumes!
Carly was cut. In past years, the final six were a case of losing a talented person every week. This year doesn’t seem the case.
